European closet tracker investigation ‘flawed’

Added 16th May 2016

The European Securities and Markets Authority’s (Esma) investigation into funds marketing themselves as active but in reality are passive, or ‘closet trackers’, underestimates the extent of the problem, according to UK investment boutique SCM Direct.

European closet tracker investigation ‘flawed’

In February, a study undertaken by Esma found that up to 15% of large, actively managed Ucits equity funds are potentially just tracking the underlying market index.

Esma research

The Esma study looked into equity funds domiciled in EU member states that were not categorised as index tracking Ucits. They had to have assets under management of more than €50m (£39.3m, $56.5m), have an inception date before 1 January 2005, and management fees of more than 0.65%.

It found more than 2,600 Ucits that met the criteria and was able to retrieve data for 1,251 Ucits sub-funds for the period 2012-2014.

Esma said that of the funds where less than 60% of the holdings differed from the benchmark, and a less than 4% tracking error, 15% could be classified as potentially being closet indexers.

Rebuttal

However, when SCM applied the same parameters to a test sample of genuine index tracking funds, they found that a number of the funds were not flagged up as trackers.  

“The Esma tests materially under-reported the levels of closet indexation."

“It is our conclusion that there may be a fundamental issue with the Esma tests regarding the pricing of retail funds,” SMC said.

The company attributed the difference to the fact virtually all mutual funds is priced at 12pm, before the benchmark closes. As a result, the performance of genuine index tracking funds, as well as closet tracking funds, appears different to the benchmark.

Materially underreported

Gina Miller, co-founder of SCM, told the Financial Times: “The Esma tests materially under-reported the levels of closet indexation. There may be a fundamental issue regarding the pricing of retail funds that means the tests are prone to misleading results.”

In response, Esma said the purpose of its analysis was only to determine “whether there was any indication of closet indexing at an EU-wide level”.

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

About Author

Kirsten Hastings

Senior Reporter

Kirsten is a senior reporter for International Adviser, covering global news stories about the financial services industry. She joined Last Word Media in October 2015 after two years working as a reporter covering the staffing and recruitment industry. Kirsten has a Masters in Financial Journalism from the University of Stirling. 

Features

 Mike Webb on reviving Rathbones’ unit trust business post-Brexit

Mike Webb on reviving Rathbones’ unit trust business...

Mike Webb talks about his mission to revitalise Rathbones’ unit trust business and the impact of the UK’s decision to leave the European Union

Analysis

Profiles

Directories

Ashburton International
Ashburton International

Ashburton Investments is a new generation investment...

Tweets

Events

IA International Portfolio Bond Forum 2017
IA International Retirement Planning Forum Dubai 2017
IA International Retirement Planning Forum Dubai 2017

Thursday 15 March,
Shangri-La Hotel, Dubai

Sponsored Content

Investment Strategy

OTHER STORIES FROM LAST WORD...