Sipp providers need to simplify charges, say experts

Added 29th June 2016

Providers of self-invested personal pension schemes (Sipps) need to simplify their charging structures to make it easier for financial advisers to compare products, experts in the industry have said.

Sipp providers need to simplify charges, say experts

It comes as new research from Momentum Pensions found 55% of advisers have been shocked in the past by Sipp providers who have levied charges they had not expected.

Until recently, the firm solely provided offshore pensions in the form of qualifying recognised overseas pension schemes (Qrops) to expats around the world, but has since expanded with the launch of its first platform Sipp product aimed at the UK market.

The survey, exclusively obtained by International Adviser, questioned 106 UK advisers and found that 74% of them find it difficult to easily compare the charging structures between Sipp providers, while 77% are actively looking for providers that are transparent with their fees.

'Lack of transparency'

Dean Mullaly, managing director of international IFA firm Mark Dean Wealth Management, told International Adviser he believes “there is an inherent lack of transparency” in the fees charged by Sipp firms.

He accused Hargreaves Lansdown, one of the largest Sipp providers in the UK, of being the worst offender when it comes to unexpected charges.

“The issue is that a lot of Sipp providers predate the flexible access drawdown which has changed their business models."

“I tried to research them and it took me absolutely ages to find out where the actually charges were hidden,” said Mullaly.

As a result, Mullaly said he picked Alliance Trust as his chosen Sipp provider, which charges a one-off flat fee of £275 to use their platform.

The fee is considered simple compared to other providers on the market.

James Hay, one of the top three Sipp firms in the UK, charges a £195 annual fee for its flagship platform product, the Modular iSIPP, which comes with 0.18% annual bps charge on the first £500,000 ($665,390, €601,909).

The product also includes three optional investment modules – whole of market, commercial property and specialist Investments – which comes with a list of charges four pages long.

Describing its product as “competitively priced”, Momentum revealed it charges a setup fee of £250, an annual fee of £250 and an annual income drawdown costs £100. The firm said there are also other dealing charges for the investments within the wrapper, although these were not disclosed.

Pension freedoms

Meanwhile, Richard Chandler, operations director of UK-based MW Pensions, a subsidiary of rival Qrops specialist Sovereign, pointed out that existing charging formats have failed to adapt to the pension freedoms introduced by the UK government last year.

“The issue is that a lot of Sipp providers predate the flexible access drawdown which has changed the way in which provider must do their calculations, so the business model has changed,” he said.

Chandler, whose firm charges a £500 flat fee for its non-platform ‘full’ Sipp service, agrees with the findings of Momentum’s survey that with the current pricing structure, advisers may find it difficult to compare products.

Describing the prices as “inconsistent with the marketplace”, he said Sipp providers could make it “a lot easier” for advisers.

Simplifying charges

He expects pension freedoms to push some Sipp providers to simplify their fees in the future – a sentiment Mullaly disagrees with, arguing that many Sipp providers are already “running close to the bone” with regards to the professional indemnity (PI) insurance they have to pay for the risk they take on. 

Chandler concedes that the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) upcoming capital adequacy rules – due to take effect in September – could mean that, historically, a large proportion of firms have been “undercharging for the risk that they are carrying”.

Inside the International Adviser - July 2016 Issue

International Adviser - July 2016

The July issue of International Adviser magazine is now available to read online. View your digital edition by clicking on the link below, or download the free International Adviser App through your app store.


Inside the latest edition:

  • Why gold is back in favour as a defensive strategy in uncertain markets
  • How the acquisition of FPI is adding value to Aviva’s Asia operations
  • International life company Unilife’s move to target expats in Europe
  • Tips on how to work with lawyers on succession planning

International Adviser is available in the iTunes App StoreGoogle Play and on Kindle Fire. To see how you can access your digital magazine click here

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

Trust management fees

Fees charged by managers are running out of control and it is time for financial authorities to reign them in. Last year my managers drew down more in fees than I did in draw down; their name was mentioned in your article. My trust needs 15% income annually to cover my draw down and management fees. It is a scandal, and a trust is like owning a time share. Managers self interests come first, and the beneficiaries a poor second.

Posted by: Tom, 29 Jun 2016

About Author

Monira Matin

Senior Reporter

Monira joined International Adviser in March 2016 from Informa Global Markets where she worked as a eurobond reporter for over two years, covering fixed income markets. She has previously held a number of editorial positions covering politics, insurance and technology. Monira has a degree in Journalism and Economics from City University.


US equities: If you can’t beat them, join them

US equities: If you can’t beat them, join them...

European investors have been dismissing US equities as too expensive for a couple of years. But as the S&P 500 continues to outperform other equity markets, appetite for the asset class is again on the...


Ashburton International
Ashburton International

Ashburton Investments is a new generation investment...



Future Advisory Forum Hong Kong 2016
Future Advisory Forum Hong Kong 2016

Tuesday 4th October 2016

Hong Kong

Future Advisory Forum Singapore 2016
Future Advisory Forum Singapore 2016

Thursday 6th October 2016


Offshore Bond Workshop Manchester 2016
Offshore Bond Workshop Manchester 2016

12th October 2016
The Midland, Manchester

Future Advisory Forum Cape Town 2016
Future Advisory Forum Cape Town 2016

Tuesday 18th October
The Vineyard, Cape Town

Investment Strategy

Sponsored Content