Tracking responsibly - are ESG index trackers any good?

Added 17th October 2016

The growing popularity of index investing is only just starting to be felt in the world of responsible investing but as the market for plain vanilla trackers becomes increasingly crowded, what does the future hold for ESG passive products?

Tracking responsibly - are ESG index trackers any good?

ESG trackers share some traits with their non-ESG peers: their portfolios are transparent and, more importantly, costs are low. Moreover, some of the SRI ETFs recently launched by iShares are cheaper than their regular counterparts.

For example, the iShares Sustainable MSCI Emerging Markets SRI ETF has a total expense ratio (TER) of 0.35%, compared with 0.68% for the non-SRI version of the product. Both compare very favourably with the 1.97% median TER of actively managed ecology funds with an ESG mandate, according to Morningstar.

Perhaps this low cost is because the US asset manager feels that it has to make up for not having taken the theme on earlier (see boxout).

But clearly, SRI-themed ETFs should not be dismissed as the latest way for asset managers to justify a higher price for a ‘fancy’ product, though these prices are introductory costs that could rise over time.

As you can see in the graph below, the MSCI SRI indices for both European and emerging market equities, have tended to outperform their plain vanilla equivalents.

Focus on CO2

This can partly be attributed to different sector and country exposures. The MSCI Emerging Markets SRI index, for example, has a strong overweight to Taiwan and India, and has an exposure of only 3% to China, compared with a 26% weighting in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index. On a sector level, the discrepancies are less dramatic (see sector and geographic exposure pie charts on opposite page).

Syntrus Achmea, one of the largest institutional investors in the Netherlands, with €109bn in assets under management, is a dedicated ESG investor. Eighty-five per cent of its actively managed equity investments have at least some form of ESG screening, and the company has introduced this to its passive portfolios as well. “We started to seriously engage with passive ESG investing in autumn 2014,” says Freddy van Mulligen, who is responsible for external manager selection at the company. 

“Sixty per cent of our passive investments on the equity side are now ESG-screened, and this is growing. Passive ESG screening allows you a great deal of flexibility in excluding companies and sectors.”

Visitor's Comments Add your comment

Add Your Comment

We won't publish your address

About Author

Tjibbe Hoekstra

Senior Reporter

Tjibbe joined Expert Investor as a senior reporter in March 2014. Before moving to London he worked as a financial news reporter for various news outlets in Amsterdam, including Reuters and ANP, the main news agency in the Netherlands. He also worked for Fondsnieuws, a website and magazine for finance professionals in the Netherlands. Tjibbe holds a MSc in Public Administration and a post-graduate diploma in Journalism.


ANALYSIS: All stars aligned for European equities

ANALYSIS: All stars aligned for European equities...Lock icon

The fact that the Euro Stoxx 50 index recorded its largest one-day gain since July 2012 on Monday suggests the importance for investors of Emmanuel Macron’s victory in the first round of the French presidential...




Canada Life International Limited
Canada Life International...

Canada Life International Canada Life House,...



IA International Portfolio Bond & Financial Planning Forum 2017
IA Best Practice Adviser Awards UK 2017
IA Best Practice Adviser Awards UK 2017

Wednesday 3 May
The Waldorf Hilton, London

IA Product & Service Awards 2017
IA Product & Service Awards 2017

Wednesday 3 May
The Waldorf Hilton, London 

IA International Investment Forum Johannesburg 2017
IA International Investment Forum Johannesburg 2017

Tuesday 16 May
The Hyatt Regency, Johannesburg

Sponsored Content

Investment Strategy