Skip to content
International Adviser
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Regions
    • United Kingdom
    • Middle East
    • Europe
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • North America
    • Latin America
  • Industry
    • Tax & Regulation
    • Products
    • Life
    • Health & Protection
    • People Moves
    • Companies
    • Offshore Bonds
    • Retirement
    • Technology
    • Platforms
  • Investment
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Alternatives
    • Multi Asset
    • Property
    • Macro Views
    • Structured Products
    • Emerging Markets
    • Commodities
  • IA 100
  • Best Practice
    • Best Practice Awards
  • Media
    • Video
    • Podcast
  • Directory
  • My IA
    • Events
    • IA Tax Panel
    • IA Intermediary Panel
    • About IA

ANNOUNCEMENT: Read more financial articles on our partner site, click here to read more.

FCA slammed over plethora of failures in British Steel scandal

By Cristian Angeloni, 21 Jul 22

It has ‘consistently been behind the curve in responding to unsuitable pension transfer advice’

The UK Public Accounts Committee has released its latest report into the British Steel Pension Scheme (BSPS) scandal which found a series of shortcomings from the financial regulator.

While the financial advice market is “designed” to safeguard consumers from making poor decisions, that was definitely not the case in the BSPS case where advisers were “financially incentivised” to provide unsuitable recommendations, the committee found.

The regulatory system left members “open to being manipulated and taken advantage of”, resulting in around 7,800 steelworkers transferring out of their defined benefit (DB) pension, losing an average of £82,600 ($98,600, €97,300) in savings.

The committee slammed the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) role in the scandal, saying it had “consistently been behind the curve in responding to unsuitable pension transfer advice”.

The members of parliament (MPs) added that despite being aware of the potential risks to consumer brought by pension legislation in 2015, the FCA “failed to take preventative action” to protect them.

The watchdog had “limited insight” and a lack of access to timely data on the DB transfer market which meant the regulator was “slow to understand the risks” BSPS members were facing and how to effectively monitor them.

This was made even worse by the FCA’s regulatory focus on larger firms, which left smaller companies “out of the spotlight”, the report found, which was also admitted by former chief executive Andrew Bailey.

But, the committee noted that the regulator proved it can act swiftly and fairly, including, when it took emergency action to protect businesses and consumers during the pandemic, and that it should have applied the same framework to cases such as BSPS.

Lack of enforcement

MPs also criticised the FCA’s failures in being sufficiently proactive or timely in using its enforcement powers.

So far, just one fine has been issued in response to the British Steel scandal while 30 enforcement actions are currently in place, which have been “ongoing for years without progress”. “[The FCA] relied on ineffective interventions during its initial response such as issuing letters to advice firms reminding them of their obligations […] rather than taking enforcement action.

“In doing so, the FCA failed to distinguish between rogue advisers and isolated instances of bad advice. Similarly, within the BSPS case there have been reports of phoenixing, in which rogue advice firms voluntarily leave the market only to repaper under different names; in response the FCA updated its guidance to raise firms’ awareness of the issue and is yet to take enforcement action.

“This highlights the FCA’s failure to deter bad actors from operating within the market.”

Redress issues

But the Public Accounts Committee also found that enforcement action has not been the only instance where the regulator has been slow to act.

The FCA’s handling over compensation to BSPS members has caused them to face “significant delays”, with many yet to receive the full sum owed to them.

Those who went down the Financial Services Compensation Scheme route “lost £21m due to FCA-imposed financial limits” – which currently stand at £85,000.

MPs noted several incongruences in compensation awarded as well, since sums have often changed according to when calculations were made.

The committee added: “Members who sought compensation early have received significantly less than those who claimed compensation after 2021. Only 25% of all BSPS members who received unsuitable advice have raised claims with redress organisations, yet the FCA has taken five years to propose a consumer redress scheme for members.

“Despite gathering evidence on the case since 2018, the FCA only began considering the potential use of a scheme and analysing its impacts in early 2021.”

But problems have been found with the proposed redress scheme. The regulator has estimated it would cost around £71.2m to compensate all those who received bad financial advice, but the committee is concerned the figure “may end up being significantly higher”.

Expectations

Seven years since the Pension Schemes Act, regulated bodies are “still not clear on the FCA’s expectations for consumer protection”, the report found.

Although the FCA identified potential risks of harm being caused to consumers when pension freedoms were introduced and regarding the speed the legislation was being implemented, it provided guidance claiming that in most cases a transfer would be unsuitable, causing confusion for advice firms.

MPs continued: “Adding to this confusion, the FCA consulted on removing its starting position in 2017, despite finding a 17% unsuitability rate for DB transfer advice across the market. Such contradictions and misalignment between the legislation and regulation of transfer advice contributed to the failings of advisers within the BSPS case.

“There are also uncertainties around the provision of professional indemnity insurance (PII), as the availability of cover has become constrained by limited providers and high costs. The FCA is yet to define its expectations for the PII industry or fully consider its effects on the stability of pension transfer advice market. The FCA has also failed to clarify its regulatory approach to other areas emerging areas of consumer risk, such as crypto asset investments.”

A spokesperson for the FCA said: “The circumstances around British Steel Pension Scheme transfers were exceptional, and we know that many members lost out due to poor advice. We will carefully consider the recommendations of the report and respond to the committee.

“We’ve proposed a scheme which should see advice firms pay over £70m of compensation to steelworkers. That’s in addition to over £70m which has already been paid out. And people affected don’t have to wait for the scheme to be in place to make a complaint.

“We’ve also made sure that only firms with the right skills and experience can provide advice on pension transfers in future – over 700 firms have stopped doing so due to our work. We’ve also learnt real lessons for the future, including improving how we work with other regulators.”

Tags: British Steel | FCA

Share this article
Follow by Email
Facebook
fb-share-icon
X (Twitter)
Post on X
LinkedIn
Share

Related Stories

  • Emerging Markets

    Aviva Investors launches Emerging Market Debt Opportunities fund

    Tax & Regulation

    UK Budget changes: What advisers need to know about long-term wealth planning

  • A red inked rubber stamp with the word Fail

    Investment

    ‘I invested £250k spinal injury payout in Godwin after asking adviser for low-risk investment – now I’ve lost everything’

    Latest news

    FCA charges Raymond Fieldhouse with money laundering


NEWSLETTER

Sign Up for International
Adviser Daily Newsletter

subscribe

  • View site map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Published by Money Map Media – part of G&M Media Ltd Copyright (c) 2024.

International Adviser covers the global intermediary market that uses cross-border insurance, investments, banking and pension products on behalf of their high-net-worth clients. No news, articles or content may be reproduced in part or in full without express permission of International Adviser. Site managed by Furness Media

polestoto

lahirtoto

warung403

warung403 login

situs warung403

lahirtoto

LAHIRTOTO

LAHIRTOTO LOGIN

lahirtoto

imgstock

Hosting Gambar

jejak filosofi yin yang dalam mahjong ways 2 bagaimana kontras visual membangun identitas permainan

ketika rekaman mahjong ways 2 dianalisis frame demi frame apa yang bisa diketahui dari transisi animasi

fenomena visual afterimage dalam mahjong ways 2 mengapa efek cahaya dapat meninggalkan kesan gerakan

membaca mahjong ways 2 melalui semiotika digital bagaimana ubin klasik berubah menjadi bahasa visual modern

mengapa narasi ritual keberuntungan sering dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 menelusuri asal kepercayaan digital

di balik tampilan mahjong ways 2 prinsip visual weight menjelaskan mengapa area tertentu lebih menarik perhatian

mahjong ways 2 dan budaya berbagi screenshot bagaimana potongan momen membentuk cerita di media sosial

ketika konsep fraktal dibandingkan dengan mahjong ways 2 mengapa pengulangan bentuk bukan bukti pola kemenangan

mengenal perceptual fluency lewat mahjong ways 2 mengapa tampilan yang familiar terasa lebih mudah dipahami

mahjong ways 2 di era konten vertikal bagaimana format video pendek mengubah cara orang melihat permainan

fenomena karakter harimau dalam fortune tiger bagaimana simbol kekuatan membentuk identitas game digital

mengapa dunia fantasi dragon hatch terasa hidup kajian animasi makhluk mitologi dalam game mobile

ketika budaya meksiko hadir dalam wild bandito bagaimana visual festival membangun narasi digital

misteri pencahayaan kristal gem saviour sword bagaimana efek refleksi menciptakan kedalaman visual

queen of bounty dan estetika bajak laut mengapa konsep petualangan masih menarik di era game modern

di balik karakter medusa ii bagaimana legenda yunani diubah menjadi sosok fantasi digital

mengapa animasi fortune ox mudah diingat mengenal psikologi bentuk dan ekspresi karakter

perpaduan seni bela diri dan animasi shaolin soccer bagaimana gerakan membangun identitas visual

ketika legenda hou yi menjadi inspirasi game digital menelusuri simbol bulan dan mitologi tiongkok

fenomena estetika jepang dalam geishas revenge bagaimana kontras warna membangun suasana dramatis

fenomena jejak perangkat di kasino digital mengapa identitas pengguna bisa dikenali meski berganti akun

ketika kasino digital memanfaatkan desain tanpa gesekan bagaimana kemudahan antarmuka mengubah perilaku

misteri saldo virtual dalam kasino digital mengapa angka di layar terasa berbeda dari uang tunai

teknologi deteksi emosi dan kasino digital seberapa jauh sistem mampu membaca respons pengguna

mengapa notifikasi kasino digital terasa mendesak mengenal fenomena urgensi buatan pada layanan online

ketika riwayat aktivitas kasino digital menjadi profil perilaku apa risikonya bagi privasi pengguna

ilusi kendali di kasino digital bagaimana tombol interaktif membentuk perasaan memiliki pengaruh

kasino digital dan fenomena kelelahan keputusan mengapa pilihan berulang bisa mengurangi ketelitian

di balik sistem loyalitas kasino digital bagaimana status member memengaruhi penilaian terhadap risiko

ketika kasino digital menggunakan personalisasi ekstrem bagaimana rekomendasi bisa mempersempit pilihan

fenomena pareidolia pada mahjong ways 2 mengapa susunan simbol acak terlihat memiliki pesan

mahjong ways 2 dan teori warna komplementer bagaimana kontras visual mengarahkan perhatian

ketika konsep yin yang dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 membedakan filosofi budaya dan mekanisme game

misteri efek hampir menang di mahjong ways 2 mengapa hasil yang meleset tipis terasa begitu dekat

mahjong ways 2 dalam perspektif neuroestetika mengapa susunan ubin tertentu terasa memuaskan

mengapa ingatan selektif memengaruhi persepsi pemain mahjong ways 2 terhadap hasil putaran

fenomena sinkronisasi audiovisual di mahjong ways 2 bagaimana otak menyatukan suara dan gerakan

ketika mitos lima elemen tiongkok dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 apa batas makna simboliknya

mahjong ways 2 dan paradoks keacakan mengapa rangkaian hasil serupa tidak membuktikan adanya pola

di balik ilusi progres mahjong ways 2 bagaimana animasi bertahap membentuk persepsi pencapaian

fenomena identitas sintetis di kasino online bagaimana akun palsu dapat mengaburkan kepercayaan pengguna

ketika sistem rekomendasi kasino online mengenali kebiasaan apa dampaknya terhadap kebebasan memilih

kasino online dan risiko manipulasi ulasan mengapa penilaian bintang tidak selalu mencerminkan pengalaman nyata

mengungkap fenomena saldo mengendap di kasino online bagaimana dana digital bisa terlupakan

di balik desain tombol kasino online mengapa penempatan warna dan ukuran dapat mengubah perilaku

ketika kasino online menggunakan avatar virtual bagaimana identitas digital memengaruhi rasa percaya

paradoks privasi di kasino online mengapa pengguna bersedia membagikan data demi kemudahan akses

teknologi pendeteksi perilaku berisiko di kasino online seberapa jauh ai dapat membantu perlindungan pengguna

kasino online dan fenomena kelelahan keputusan mengapa interaksi berulang dapat melemahkan pertimbangan

munculnya ekosistem afiliasi kasino online bagaimana insentif promosi dapat memengaruhi netralitas informasi

fenomena pareidolia digital dalam mahjong ways 2 mengapa susunan simbol acak terlihat seperti pesan tersembunyi

mahjong ways 2 dan teori informasi bagaimana ketidakpastian dapat dijelaskan melalui konsep matematika

ketika kalender lunar dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 mengapa tanggal tertentu dianggap membawa keberuntungan

mengenal efek anchoring di mahjong ways 2 bagaimana hasil awal memengaruhi ekspektasi berikutnya

antara numerologi tiongkok dan mahjong ways 2 mengapa angka tertentu memiliki makna simbolis

mahjong ways 2 dalam perspektif ekonomi perilaku mengapa keputusan kecil bisa terasa semakin penting

bagaimana ai generatif membentuk narasi prediksi mahjong ways 2 yang terlihat ilmiah tetapi belum teruji

fenomena time distortion pada mahjong ways 2 mengapa durasi permainan bisa terasa lebih singkat

mahjong ways 2 dan prinsip salience bagaimana efek cahaya membuat simbol tertentu lebih menonjol

ketika astrologi timur dibawa ke mahjong ways 2 mengenal batas antara tradisi budaya dan probabilitas

Mahjong Ways 2 pada Browser dengan Fitur Preload Halaman, Mengapa Waktu Muat Awal Bisa Berbeda

Gates of Olympus di Smartphone dengan USB Tethering, Mengenal Perbedaan Koneksi Kabel dan Hotspot

Mengamati Scatter Starlight Princess melalui Video Hasil Crop, Mengapa Bagian Layar yang Hilang Penting

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Layar dengan Pelindung Privasi, Mengapa Warna dan Sudut Pandang Terlihat Berbeda

Mahjong Wins 2 saat Browser Meminta Izin Notifikasi, Memahami Perbedaan Pesan Situs dan Informasi Permainan

Mahjong Ways 2 pada Layar AMOLED dengan Refresh Rate Adaptif, Mengapa Animasi Tidak Selalu Terlihat Lebih Halus

Membaca Riwayat Putaran Gates of Olympus melalui Tangkapan Layar, Mengapa Satu Gambar Tidak Cukup Menjelaskan Hasil

Starlight Princess Dibuka saat Mode Hemat Baterai Aktif, Mengenal Perubahan Kinerja Browser dan Animasi

Membandingkan Sweet Bonanza dan Sweet Bonanza 1000 melalui Tampilan Pengali, Memahami Perbedaan Informasi pada Layar

Mahjong Wins 2 pada Smartphone dengan Fitur Touch Sampling Rate Tinggi, Mengapa Respons Sentuhan Tetap Bisa Terlambat

Gates of Olympus saat Smartphone Terhubung ke Monitor Eksternal, Mengenal Perbedaan Resolusi dan Skala Tampilan

Mengamati Animasi Scatter Starlight Princess melalui Rekaman Layar, Mengapa Frame Video Bisa Berbeda dari Tampilan Asli

Wild Bounty Showdown pada HP dengan Fitur Pengisian Bypass, Memahami Perbedaan Aliran Daya dan Suhu Perangkat

Membandingkan Mahjong Ways dan Starlight Princess dari Kecepatan Animasi, Mengapa Durasi Visual Bukan Ukuran Peluang

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Browser dengan Fitur Memory Saver, Mengapa Tab yang Tidak Aktif Bisa Dimuat Ulang

Mahjong Ways 2 pada HP dengan Fitur Game Booster, Mengapa Mode Performa Tidak Selalu Mempercepat Animasi

Gates of Olympus Dibuka melalui WiFi 6, Memahami Mengapa Koneksi Cepat Masih Bisa Mengalami Jeda

Scatter Starlight Princess dalam Video Slow Motion, Mengapa Gerakan Lambat Bisa Mengubah Persepsi Durasi

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Layar dengan Fitur HDR, Mengenal Perbedaan Warna Cerah dan Detail Animasi

Mahjong Wins 2 saat Browser Mengaktifkan Penghemat Data, Mengapa Elemen Halaman Bisa Dimuat Berbeda

Membandingkan Animasi Gates of Olympus pada HP dan Tablet, Mengapa Ukuran Layar Tidak Menentukan Kecepatan

Starlight Princess saat Smartphone Mengalami Thermal Throttling, Mengenal Dampak Suhu terhadap Performa

Membaca Informasi Scatter Mahjong Ways melalui Video Kompresi Tinggi, Mengapa Detail Kecil Bisa Menghilang

Wild Bounty Showdown Dibuka pada Browser dengan Mode Gelap Paksa, Mengapa Warna Permainan Bisa Berubah

Gates of Olympus dan Fitur DNS Pribadi pada Android, Memahami Perbedaan Resolusi Domain dan Kecepatan Internet

Mahjong Ways 2 pada Smartphone dengan Layar LTPO, Mengapa Refresh Rate Dapat Berubah saat Animasi Berjalan

Mengenal Risiko Video Scatter Starlight Princess yang Diedit AI, Mengapa Gerakan Simbol Perlu Diperiksa

Sweet Bonanza Dibuka melalui Browser dengan Pemblokir Iklan, Mengapa Sebagian Elemen Situs Bisa Terganggu

Mahjong Wins 2 pada HP dengan Penyimpanan Hampir Penuh, Memahami Pengaruh Ruang Kosong terhadap Browser

Membandingkan Tampilan Pengali Gates of Olympus dan Starlight Princess, Mengapa Simbol Serupa Memiliki Aturan Berbeda

Wild Bounty Showdown pada Smartphone dengan Mode Satu Tangan, Mengapa Tata Letak Browser Bisa Berubah

Mahjong Ways saat Browser Memakai Terjemahan Otomatis, Mengapa Istilah Permainan Bisa Berubah Makna

Starlight Princess dalam Rekaman Layar 120 FPS, Mengapa Video Tetap Bisa Terlihat Patah-Patah

Gates of Olympus saat HP Menggunakan VPN, Mengenal Perbedaan Latensi Jaringan dan Respons Animasi

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Smartphone dengan Fitur Adaptive Brightness, Mengapa Kecerahan Layar Bisa Berubah Sendiri

Mahjong Ways 2 pada Browser dengan Fitur Tab Freeze, Mengapa Animasi Bisa Berhenti Setelah Berpindah Aplikasi

Gates of Olympus saat HP Mengaktifkan Mode Perlindungan Baterai, Memahami Perbedaan Batas Pengisian dan Performa

Membaca Simbol Scatter Starlight Princess dari Foto Layar, Mengapa Pantulan Cahaya Bisa Mengaburkan Detail

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Tablet dengan Keyboard Bluetooth, Mengapa Tombol Fisik Belum Tentu Berfungsi di Browser

Mahjong Wins 2 saat Smartphone Menggunakan Resolusi Layar Otomatis, Mengapa Ketajaman Tampilan Bisa Berubah

Membandingkan Gates of Olympus dan Sweet Bonanza melalui Diagram Alur, Memahami Perbedaan Tahapan Animasi

Wild Bounty Showdown pada HP dengan Fitur Audio Spasial, Mengapa Efek Suara Tidak Selalu Berubah

Mahjong Ways 2 dalam Rekaman Video dengan Variable Frame Rate, Mengapa Gerakan Simbol Bisa Terlihat Tidak Konsisten

Starlight Princess saat Browser Memblokir Cookie Pihak Ketiga, Mengenal Pengaruhnya terhadap Sesi Pengguna

Gates of Olympus pada Smartphone dengan Fitur WiFi Calling, Mengapa Panggilan Tidak Menentukan Kelancaran Browser

Mahjong Wins 2 pada Layar Lipat dengan Mode Multiwindow, Mengapa Antarmuka Bisa Menyesuaikan Ukuran Jendela

Mengenal Metadata Video Scatter Starlight Princess, Mengapa Tanggal Pembuatan Belum Tentu Menunjukkan Waktu Kejadian

Sweet Bonanza saat Browser Mengaktifkan Hardware Acceleration, Memahami Peran GPU dalam Menampilkan Animasi

Mahjong Ways 2 pada HP dengan Fitur Eye Comfort, Mengapa Warna Simbol Bisa Terlihat Lebih Hangat

Membandingkan Riwayat Visual Gates of Olympus dan Starlight Princess, Mengapa Rekaman Pendek Memiliki Keterbatasan

Wild Bounty Showdown saat Smartphone Menggunakan Hotspot, Mengapa Kecepatan Jaringan Bisa Berubah

Mahjong Wins 2 pada Browser dengan Pengaturan Ukuran Font Besar, Mengapa Susunan Elemen Halaman Bisa Bergeser

Starlight Princess dalam Video dengan Interpolasi Frame AI, Mengapa Animasi Tambahan Tidak Mewakili Rekaman Asli

Gates of Olympus saat Android Mengaktifkan Private Compute Core, Memahami Batas Fitur Privasi dan Aktivitas Browser

Sweet Bonanza 1000 pada Monitor dengan Fitur Variable Refresh Rate, Mengapa Gerakan Tidak Selalu Mengikuti Kemampuan Layar

ketika teori entropi dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 mengapa keacakan sulit dipahami secara intuitif

mahjong ways 2 dan fenomena dopamin digital bagaimana antisipasi memengaruhi perhatian pengguna

misteri angka delapan dalam budaya tiongkok apa kaitannya dengan simbol keberuntungan mahjong ways 2

mengapa prediksi ai tentang mahjong ways 2 bisa terlihat akurat padahal belum tentu terbukti

antara ilusi frekuensi dan simbol scatter mahjong ways 2 mengapa hal yang dicari terasa sering muncul

mahjong ways 2 dalam kajian antropologi digital bagaimana simbol tradisional mendapat makna baru

fenomena keputusan otomatis saat bermain mahjong ways 2 mengapa kebiasaan terbentuk tanpa disadari

di balik ritme mahjong ways 2 bagaimana perpaduan audio dan visual membentuk pengalaman interaktif

mengapa konsep hari keberuntungan sering dikaitkan dengan mahjong ways 2 menelusuri bias interpretasi

ketika data putaran mahjong ways 2 dijadikan grafik apa yang bisa dan tidak bisa disimpulkan

Di Balik Video Scatter Hitam Mahjong Ways 2 yang Viral, Ada Detail Rekaman yang Sering Terlewat

Ketika Gates of Olympus Terlihat Berbeda di Dua Ponsel, Belum Tentu Versi Gamenya Berubah

Bukan Sekadar Angka RTP, Ini yang Perlu Dipahami dari Informasi Statistik Starlight Princess

Satu Cuplikan Sweet Bonanza 1000 Bisa Memunculkan Banyak Tafsir, Bagaimana Cara Membaca Konteksnya

Jejak Digital di Balik Klaim Pola Mahjong Ways, Saat Tangkapan Layar Dianggap Sebagai Bukti

Mengapa Komunitas Gates of Olympus Bisa Memiliki Kesimpulan Berbeda dari Rekaman yang Sama

Fenomena Video Starlight Princess Tanpa Sumber Asli, Seberapa Jauh Keaslian Konten Bisa Diperiksa

Dari Simbol hingga Animasi, Cara Sweet Bonanza dan Mahjong Ways Menyampaikan Informasi Permainan

Ketika AI Diminta Menebak Hasil Mahjong Ways 2 dari Video, Apa yang Sebenarnya Bisa Dianalisis

Ramai Dibahas sebagai RTP Live Gates of Olympus, Mengapa Angka di Situs Berbeda Perlu Ditelusuri